PETG or PLA for rack panels, and why we only use PETG

The 1U blanking panel at an angle, showing the textured finish of the black PETG along its length

If you print, you've had this argument in a forum thread already. This is the longer version of our side of it: what actually goes wrong with a rack panel, in what order it goes wrong, and why you'll find no temperatures anywhere on this page.

Nothing here is a case against PLA

PLA is the right first answer for most of what comes off a printer. It's cheap, it's quick, it's forgiving about draughts and bed levelling and everything else, and it'll hand you a surface finish that PETG makes you work for. If somebody's just got their first machine, telling them to start anywhere else is bad advice.

A rack panel is one of the few places it falls down. Not on day one, which is the awkward part. On day one a PLA panel is indistinguishable from ours, and slightly prettier.

The trouble is that all three of the things that break a rack panel take weeks or months to happen, and none of them happens on a bench where you can watch.

What actually goes wrong, in the order it goes wrong

Heat, and it's slow

A rack is a warm box that stays warm. That's the whole point of it. Cupboard door shut, something under load, a hot week on top of that, and the inside of the rack sits at a temperature it never leaves for months at a time.

Nothing dramatic happens. Nothing melts, nothing droops in front of you, and there's no moment where you catch it. What you get is a slow sag, and one afternoon you notice the panel nearest whatever runs hottest has gone from flat to not quite flat. Once a panel has taken that set, it doesn't come back.

The reason this catches people out is that a blanking panel isn't holding anything up, so it feels like heat can't matter. It isn't carrying a load. It's carrying itself, across a span, warm, for a very long time.

The bolt hole

Four bolts. That's every mechanical demand anybody makes of a blanking panel, and it all lands in four small rings of plastic.

They get done up by a person with a screwdriver, at whatever tightness that person thinks is about right, which is usually a bit more than it needs to be. PLA doesn't squash a little and complain. It cracks. Often it cracks around the hole where you can't see it, under the screw head, and you find out weeks later when the corner is loose and you can't work out why.

There's a printing angle to this that anyone who's snapped a part will recognise. A printed panel is at its weakest between layers, and a flat panel's bolt hole is exactly where that weakness meets the load. PETG gives a fraction before it lets go, and that fraction is the difference between a panel you can do up firmly and a panel you have to be gentle with for the rest of its life.

Being taken apart again

This is the one nobody ever tests, because tests happen on day one and this failure needs day sixty.

You'll pull a panel to run a cable. You'll move the switch up a U. You'll add a second Pi and reshuffle everything below it. Anything in a rack you actually use comes out and goes back more times than you'd guess, and every time, the same ring of plastic gets compressed by the same screw head.

PLA's third time is worse than its first. That's fatigue, and it's where a material with a bit of give in it quietly wins.

Why there are no temperatures on this page

We could put two figures here, one for PLA and one for PETG, and the page would look more authoritative for it. We're not going to, for two reasons that are worth more to you than the figures would be.

The first is whose PLA and whose PETG. Filament varies by maker, by batch, by colour and by how dry it was on the day you printed it. A number that's right about one spool tells you very little about the one on your shelf.

The second is what the figure was measured on. Published values come off standardised samples, under a stated load, at a stated rate, in a lab. Your panel is a printed part, so it's stronger in one direction than another, and it's sitting in a cupboard being warmed unevenly for months on end. That isn't the same experiment. It isn't close to the same experiment.

There's also more than one number in circulation. Glass transition and heat deflection are different measurements answering different questions, and the one quoted at you in a thread tends to be whichever flatters the point being made.

So when somebody quotes you a temperature, ask two questions. Which datasheet, and which test method. If the answer comes back as a link to the actual document, you've met somebody worth listening to. If it comes back as "everyone knows", you've learned what you needed to know anyway.

What isn't in dispute anywhere, and what we'll say plainly: PETG takes more heat than PLA before it starts to move. The direction is settled. The number isn't ours to hand you.

If you're making your own panel, here's what we'd tell a friend

Print it in PETG rather than PLA, and print it thicker than the file gives you. Most free panels are drawn thin because thin prints fast, and thin bows between the rails and cracks at the bolt hole first.

Dry the filament. PETG is fussier than PLA about moisture and it'll show you every bit of it in the surface and in the strength.

Put extra walls around the bolt holes rather than leaning on infill to hold a screw. Use a washer under the head, because it spreads the load over more plastic than a screw head does on its own. And stop tightening when it's tight.

If you want to beat PETG on heat, ASA and ABS will do it. They'll also want an enclosure, decent ventilation and a tolerance for warping. That's a lot of ceremony for a blank panel, but if you've already got the enclosure, you already knew that.

And if all you've got is PLA, your rack runs cool and the door stays open, it'll very likely be fine for a good while. It's your rack, it's in front of you, and you'll see it go before anyone else does.

Buy it or print it

SUNLU black PETG, across the whole range

Every part we sell is black PETG. Not the panels in PETG and the accessories in something cheaper. All of it, the same material, the same black.

There isn't a budget PLA version and there isn't going to be. We'd sell it cheaper and ship it quicker, and the panel above whatever runs hottest would be the one coming back to us.

PETG costs us more per roll, prints slower and is fussier to get a clean face out of. Those are our three problems, and we'd rather have them than yours.

Everything is made in small batches here in Tewkesbury, checked by hand, and held in stock.

Material settled, spacing not

Whichever way you go on plastic, the thing that decides whether a panel is any use to you is the hole spacing on your own rack, and that's two minutes with a tape measure. Our 1U panel is black PETG, in stock, out in a day or two, free postage anywhere in the UK. If your rack is an odd one, send us a photo of the rails before you order, because we'd rather answer a question than take a return

See the panel

Will it fit my rack?

Before you go

Every guide here exists because somebody emailed and asked. If yours is not answered, ask it, and one of the two of us will answer.

Check it fits your rack Tell me when the next product lands