10 inch rack vs 19 inch rack: which one should you buy

The Four Layers Cube from a front corner: a black 5U 10 inch rack with two carry handles on top, the open front with its two rails of square holes, and a side panel with an oval hand hole and slanted vent slots

We make parts for 10 inch racks, so you already know which way we're supposed to lean. Plenty of people should buy a 19 inch rack instead, and it's a much better thing to work out now than after a very large box has arrived.

Two different hobbies that happen to share a word

Nineteen inch is the size the whole industry settled on decades ago. There's a real standard behind it, EIA-310, and it's why a switch made by one company bolts into a rack made by another without anybody thinking about it. Racks, rails, shelves, patch panels, power strips, cage nuts, all of it exists in every price bracket, and a lot of it turns up second hand for very little because businesses replace kit on a cycle whether it's worn out or not.

Ten inch grew up somewhere else entirely. It came out of home labs, single board computers and people who wanted their kit tidy without giving up half a room to it. There's no standard body behind it and no official 10 inch specification. What there is instead is a spacing between the mounting holes that most makers have settled on by habit, which is why we publish ours rather than printing a badge on the box.

So the choice isn't really between two sizes. It's between two supply chains, and they behave completely differently.

Three things, and they're all real

  • A standard that's actually a standard. Buy a 1U anything and it fits. Nobody has to measure anything.
  • A second hand market. Decommissioned switches, servers and rails go for a fraction of new, and the money you save on the rack usually buys the kit that goes in it.
  • Everything exists. Whatever odd thing you need, somebody has made it, and there are four versions of it at four prices.

Also three, and they're the ones people underrate until they've lived with a rack

  • It fits where you live. A shelf, a cupboard, an alcove, the corner of an office. It doesn't need its own room and it doesn't need the door left open.
  • It's quiet, because of what goes in it. Ten inch racks tend to hold Pis, mini PCs, a small switch, a NAS. None of that is fighting to cool itself with a fan the size of a fifty pence piece.
  • It can look like furniture. Fill the gaps in the front and a rack stops reading as equipment. That's most of why people buy panels off us, and we'll come back to it.

The four that catch people out

Every comparison you'll read covers width and price. These are the four that actually change how you feel about the thing six months in.

Noise

Cheap second hand 19 inch kit is cheap because it was built for a server room, and a server room has a door and nobody sitting behind it. Small fans spinning fast move a lot of air and make a noise you can hear through a wall. Plenty of people buy a bargain switch, run it for a week, and quietly put it on a shelf in the garage.

Depth

Width is the number in the name and depth is the number that ruins your afternoon. A 19 inch rack is deep, and the kit designed for it is deeper still, and then you need room behind for cables that don't like being bent. Measure the space you've got, front to back, before you measure anything else. Ten inch racks are shallower, but the same rule applies to a shelf or a tray: depth decides it, not width.

The wasted space in a 10 inch rack

This is the one nobody warns you about on our side of the fence. A Raspberry Pi is small. A 10 inch rack unit is not. Put the Pi in the middle and you've got a strip of nothing on either side of it, and that strip is where a rack starts looking untidy no matter how neatly you've done the cables. It's solvable, and it's worth knowing about before you're standing there with a screwdriver wondering why it doesn't look like the photos.

Ten inch kit is bought new

There's no decommissioned 10 inch gear, because no business ever ran any. Nothing comes off a lease and lands on eBay for thirty quid. That means the format is smaller, newer and mostly made by small outfits, us included, and you pay new prices for most of what goes in it. It also means there's no standard, which is why a panel that fits one 10 inch rack can miss on another, and why the first thing we ever tell anybody is to measure the hole spacing.

The two minute check with a tape measure

Neither of these is the beginner option. They're just different

Buy a 19 inch rack if

  • You want second hand enterprise kit, and the price of it is a big part of why you're doing this.
  • You've got somewhere to put it where noise doesn't matter. A garage, a loft, a cellar, a cupboard under the stairs with a door that shuts.
  • You're going to keep adding to it. Nineteen inch scales in a way 10 inch doesn't, and there's no ceiling on what you can bolt in.
  • You need something specific that only exists in 19 inch, which is most rack mounted things.

Buy a 10 inch rack if

  • Your kit is Pis, mini PCs, a small switch, maybe a NAS, and none of it needs a rack that could hold a server.
  • It's going to live in a room people also live in.
  • Space is the constraint, and it's the one thing you can't order more of.
  • You want the thing to look finished rather than industrial.

If you're somewhere in the middle, the tiebreaker is usually the room rather than the kit. Noise and depth are much harder to fix later than a missing shelf.

What we'd say if you rang us

We make 10 inch parts, so take this with that in mind. If somebody describes a garage, a bargain switch and a plan to run twelve services, we'd tell them to buy 19 inch and enjoy it. If they describe a home office, a Pi, a switch and a partner who'd notice, 10 inch every time. Most people asking already know which one they are, they just want somebody to say it out loud.

And if you've already got a 10 inch rack and you're wondering whether our panels fit it, that's a different question with a proper answer.

Will it fit my rack?

See the 1U blanking panel

Months away from buying anything?

That's fine, and it's most people who read this one. We're two people in Tewkesbury making parts for 10 inch racks, there's more of the range on the bench, and our own rack is now on sale. One email when something's finished and on sale. That's the whole list, and one click stops it.

Tell me when the next one lands

Before you go

Every guide here exists because somebody emailed and asked. If yours is not answered, ask it, and one of the two of us will answer.

Check it fits your rack Tell me when the next product lands